Aditya Greens
Menu

What is the Payback period and the Financial feasibility of the solar roof in India?

14/4/2015

0 Comments

 
In the previous article,What is the average cost of solar roof in India ?, we learned that  the average cost of the solar roof in India is Rs. 83 /watt to Rs. 91 / watt (without battery back up).
Now let us determine the Payback period and the financial feasibility of the project.
The Payback period is the time required to cover your initial investment made in purchasing and installing the solar roof at your residence. We will determine the financial feasibility of the project through Net Present Value method, which is done by summing all the future savings after discounting them to the present value and subtracting the initial investment.
The following is the step-by-step procedure, which tells on how to determine the payback period and the feasibility of the solar roof:

(1) Determine the average cost of your solar roof

Here we are assuming that you have installed 1 KW system at your roof top which costs you in between Rs. 83,000 to Rs. 91,000. You can get the cost for the higher wattage like 2 KW or 3 KW by simply multiplying it by average cost per watt, which is Rs. 83/watt – Rs. 91/watt

(2) Determine the daily average number of sun hours

You can find this data from the official website of renewable energy of your state.  The average number of daily sun hours in Delhi/NCR is 5.5, therefore I am taking this value in the calculation.

(3) Calculate the units generated by your solar roof

Your 1 KW system will generate 1 KW x 5.5 hours = 5.5 KW-Hr or 5.5 units in a day under ideal conditions, that is when we assume that there will be no energy conversion losses and heating losses. But in actual conditions, there are certain losses which reduce your output power. Here we assume that our system is 85% efficient, which means that it will generate 5.5 units x 0.85 = 4.675 units in a day. The 15% of the energy will be lost as:
  • The conversion from solar energy to DC electrical energy
  • DC energy to AC energy
  • Dissipation of energy as heat when it passes through wires

Understanding the performance of your solar panel

When you purchase the good quality solar panel, the manufacturer provides you the performance warranty on it. It states that the solar panel will perform at 90% in first 10 years and then 80% from 11th to 25th year.
  • (Please read "Seven points to consider before buying solar panels for your home")
Therefore,
  • From 1 to 10 years of operation, your system will generate 90 % of 4.675 units = 4.21 units
  • The efficiency of the system will further reduce by another 10% in 11th till 25th years of operation, then the system will generate 80% of 4.675 units = 3.74 units. Please look at the table below:

Period

Panel Efficiency

Units generated

1 - 10 years

90%

90 % of 4.675 units = 4.21 units

11 - 25 years

80%

80 % of 4.675 units = 3.74 units

 

Find the average rate of electricity per unit in your area

The electricity that you receive from the grid comes at a cost, which is generally expressed as the rate per unit consumed. The rate of the units’ consumption is divided into slabs, for first 200 units consumed, the rate of units consumed is less and for higher consumption, the slab rate increases accordingly. You can find this by simply dividing your monthly bill by the number of units consumed in a particular month. You will get the more accurate average value if you divide the total bill of a year by the number of units consumed in that particular year. Anyhow, I am taking the average rate of Rs. 4.5 / unit.

Include the maintenance cost of the system

Your system will need maintenance, after installation, on regular basis. The maintenance process will involve the following activities:
  • Regular cleaning of the solar panels
  • Checking and tightening of the loose connections, fuses and switches in the system
  • Checking and service, if required, the inverter section of the system
  • Regularly monitoring the output of the system
(Please read "Factors to consider before implementing solar PV system at your home")
During initial years of operation, the cost of maintenance will be less and afterwards it will start increasing with the age of the system. We assume that it will cost us around 2% per annum of the cost of the system or you can take 10 %  per annum of your yearly savings as your maintenance cost. I am taking the latter assumption in this example.

The electricity from grid will not remain at Rs. 4.5 / unit forever

By looking at the past trend, the rate of the electricity is growing at an average rate of 8% per annum. In order to get the realistic picture, we need to consider this in our accounting to evaluate the payback period. Here, we assume that the rate of electricity will grow at the rate of 8% per annum till the life of the system which is 25 years.

Summarizing all the details in the form of the table to get the Payback period

Year

Daily average sun hours (Hours)

System is 85% efficient

Panel efficiency (%)

Units generated (No.)

Rate of electricity (Rs./unit)

Yearly savings (Rs.)

Maintenance cost @ 10 % of the Yearly savings (Rs.)

Net Yearly savings (Rs.)

Cumulative savings (Rs.)

1

5.5

4.675

90% efficiency

4.21

4.5

             6,915

                           691

          6,223

               6,223

2

5.5

4.675

4.21

4.9

             7,530

                           753

          6,777

            13,000

3

5.5

4.675

4.21

5.2

             7,991

                           799

          7,192

            20,192

4

5.5

4.675

4.21

5.6

             8,605

                           861

          7,745

            27,936

5

5.5

4.675

4.21

6

             9,220

                           922

          8,298

            36,234

6

5.5

4.675

4.21

6.4

             9,835

                           983

          8,851

            45,085

7

5.5

4.675

4.21

6.8

          10,449

                       1,045

          9,404

            54,490

8

5.5

4.675

4.21

7.3

          11,218

                       1,122

       10,096

            64,585

9

5.5

4.675

4.21

7.8

          11,986

                       1,199

       10,787

            75,373

10

5.5

4.675

4.21

8.3

          12,754

                       1,275

       11,479

            86,851

11

5.5

4.675

80% efficiency

3.74

8.9

          12,149

                       1,215

       10,934

            97,786

12

5.5

4.675

3.74

9.5

          12,969

                       1,297

       11,672

         109,458

13

5.5

4.675

3.74

10.2

          13,924

                       1,392

       12,532

         121,989

14

5.5

4.675

3.74

10.9

          14,880

                       1,488

       13,392

         135,381

15

5.5

4.675

3.74

11.7

          15,972

                       1,597

       14,375

         149,755

16

5.5

4.675

3.74

12.5

          17,064

                       1,706

       15,357

         165,113

17

5.5

4.675

3.74

13.4

          18,292

                       1,829

       16,463

         181,576

18

5.5

4.675

3.74

14.3

          19,521

                       1,952

       17,569

         199,145

19

5.5

4.675

3.74

15.3

          20,886

                       2,089

       18,797

         217,942

20

5.5

4.675

3.74

16.4

          22,388

                       2,239

       20,149

         238,091

21

5.5

4.675

3.74

17.5

          23,889

                       2,389

       21,500

         259,591

22

5.5

4.675

3.74

18.7

          25,527

                       2,553

       22,975

         282,566

23

5.5

4.675

3.74

20

          27,302

                       2,730

       24,572

         307,138

24

5.5

4.675

3.74

21.4

          29,213

                       2,921

       26,292

         333,429

25

5.5

4.675

3.74

22.9

          31,261

                       3,126

       28,135

         361,564

 

  • The life of the project is 25 years
  • Formula for the Yearly savings = Units generated x rate of electricity per unit x 365 days
  • Net yearly savings = Yearly savings – Yearly maintenance cost

The payback period

Now to get the Payback period, you can see in the table in between 10th and the 11th year, the cumulative cost exceeds the total cost of the system, which is Rs. 91,000. Therefore, the Payback period of the system is in between 10 and 11 years, that is your solar roof will recover your initial investment in approximately 11 years. Your solar roof will give Rs. 3, 62,564.20 in 25 years. Your net savings will be Rs. 3, 62,564.20 minus your initial investment (Rs. 91,000) = Rs. 2, 71,564 in 25 years.
The main disadvantage of the Payback period method is that it does not take in to consideration the time value of money. The yearly savings or income that your solar roof will generate in future, when discounted, say by the rate of inflation, will have less purchase value in present.
Therefore, to get the more realistic value of your solar roof, we need to calculate the Net Present Value of the future savings or income generated by the solar roof.

The Net Present value

  • Net Present Value = Sum of present value of all the future savings by the solar roof – The initial investment
If,
  • NPV < 0, then solar roof is not a feasible option and it is rejected
  • NPV > 0, then the project is feasible and it is accepted
I am taking the discount rate as the rate of Inflation, which is 7%. Now, discounting all the future net saving by this rate we get:

Future net savings (Rs.)

Discount rate @ 7%

Discounted savings or the present value of the savings (Rs.)

              6,223.41

1.07

5816

              6,776.64

1.16

5842

              7,191.54

1.25

5753

              7,744.68

1.35

5737

              8,297.91

1.46

5684

              8,851.14

1.58

5602

              9,404.28

1.71

5500

            10,095.75

1.85

5457

            10,787.31

2

5394

            11,478.78

2.16

5314

            10,934.46

2.33

4693

            11,671.65

2.52

4632

            12,531.60

2.72

4607

            13,391.64

2.94

4555

            14,374.53

3.18

4520

            15,357.42

3.43

4477

            16,463.07

3.7

4449

            17,568.81

4

4392

            18,797.40

4.32

4351

            20,148.84

4.67

4315

            21,500.37

5.04

4266

            22,974.66

5.44

4223

            24,571.80

5.88

4179

            26,291.79

6.35

4140

            28,134.72

6.86

4101

Total

121999

 

  • NPV = Rs. 1, 21,999 – Rs. 91,000 (Initial Investment)
  • NPV = Rs. 30, 999, which is > zero
Hence, the project is feasible and acceptable.

Conclusion

The Indian residential solar roof of 1 KW has a payback period of 10 – 11 years and it is a financially feasible project.
As you increase the wattage of the solar roof:
  • The overall cost of the system will decrease due to economies of scale
  • The Payback period of the project will reduce because of reduction in the Initial investment
  • The Net Present value of the project will increase.
*(I have tried my level best to make practical and relevant assumptions, so as to get the most realistic view of the project's feasibility)

Related Articles:

  • How to choose the correct size (Length x Width) of solar panel for your roof top?
  • How to size the panels of your solar power system?
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    solar feasibility spreadsheet
    Determines the techno-economic viability of your solar-roof
    Are you a solar Installer or the manufacturer? 
    Yes, register here FREE!

    RSS Feed

    View my profile on LinkedIn
    sales and marketing
    design solar power system
  • Determine & evaluate the complete techno-economic feasibility of your Solar Roof through my Residential Solar Feasibility Spreadsheet
  • Learn to design the grid-tied residential solar power system by yourself.......Read more
Copyright @ Adityagreens. All rights reserved
Photos used under Creative Commons from Felipe Valduga, FutUndBeidl
  • Solar
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Personal Finance
  • Self Improvement
  • E- Products
  • Solar Feasibility Spreadsheet
  • About
  • Tools
  • Privacy
  • Solar
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Personal Finance
  • Self Improvement
  • E- Products
  • Solar Feasibility Spreadsheet
  • About
  • Tools
  • Privacy
✕